Surgical Techniques – Total Hip Replacement
Your hip pain from arthritis has gotten so bad that you can no longer function well or tolerate the pain with even simple daily activities. The evaluation of your hip by physical exam and a careful review of your X-ray indicates that your hip is extensively worn. You are getting no relief with the more conservative measures and now you are wondering about your next step. What can be done now?
The answer may well be a total hip replacement done with the most advanced minimally invasive surgical techniques and rehabilitation program available anywhere in the world. As a recognized leader, teacher and innovator in minimally invasive surgical techniques for total hip replacement surgery, Dr. Robert Zehr of the Zehr Center for Orthopaedics has had the opportunity to refine the various aspects of the surgical experience for his patients both in the operating room and in the care postoperatively. Currently, Dr. Zehr does more hip replacements than any other surgeon in Collier County as recorded by the Florida Agency for Health Care Administration(1).
In addition, Dr. Zehr has developed a safe and innovative program to provide total hip replacement as an “outpatient surgery”. Younger, healthy patients can completely avoid a hospital setting and its inherent risks. YOU get your hip replacement and go directly home shortly afterward…the same day! This is the “front edge” of hip and knee replacement technology across the country and is quickly becoming the preferred setting for the young, active, working patient who needs to recover quickly to get back to their family and lifestyle. Check it out at …. Seaside Surgery Center in Naples, FL where Dr. Zehr and colleagues are setting the bar very high in the innovative programs to provide patients the best cutting edge technology available in the country.
Total Hip Replacement Surgery is certainly not new or uncommon. In fact, last year it is estimated that some 300,000 Americans underwent this highly successful operation to relieve the pain of an arthritic or broken hip joint. You may not be aware, but surgical techniques can vary greatly among different surgeons based on training, skill and experience. It is worth your time to become aware of these variations and how they might apply to you.
The most experienced surgeons become well versed in the technique that they have used for years, yet the question for surgeons and patients always remains–can it be done better? The answer is unequivocally — YES!
Direct Anterior Approach
One of the most exciting advances in the surgical technique of hip replacement surgery has been realized with the use of the “Direct Anterior Approach” to the hip joint which is Dr. Zehr’s preferred approach for this type of surgery. Curiously, this sophisticated surgical approach has been adopted by only ~5% of hip surgeons throughout the U.S. as their method of choice. Under ordinary circumstances, typical Medicare aged patients who have hip replacement done through the direct anterior approach with Dr. Zehr are able to go home after a one night stay in the hospital.
You may be asking yourself — “Why is this “approach” such an advancement?” Specifically, a simple change in the direction from which the surgeon enters the hip joint, the “anterior approach” to the hip (coming in from the front of the hip) is quickly becoming the most sought after surgical approach by discerning patients who need a hip replacement. The reasons for the tremendous interest in this surgical technique are the multiple advantages it provides to the patient.
Advantage One: Faster Recovery. Patients get up walking full weight bearing on their operative hip the same day of surgery shortly after returning from the recovery area. Many physically fit patients need only a cane to walk about in the hospital and are able to start general activities within a few weeks. While it may take patients many months to fully recover following conventional hip replacement surgery, the anterior approach technique enables patients often to recover and return to activities such as golf, tennis, biking and of course distance walking in as short as four weeks.
Advantage Two: Minimally Invasive. The anterior approach to hip replacement is the most minimally invasive choice for people suffering from arthritis, hip pain, hip fracture, stiffness and limited hip movement. A small 3″ – 4″ incision is created over the anterolaterall aspect of the hip. No muscle is cut or detached from bone in this approach. Some muscles in the front of the hip are temporarily pushed apart to allow work on the bones of the hip joint but are left uninjured and completely functional in this approach. This, of course, results is far less pain than is typical in other approaches to the hip used by most surgeons and compliments the faster recovery.
Advantage Three: Less Restrictive. After conventional hip replacement surgery, patients must limit flexing of the hip to no more than 60 to 90 degrees, which complicates normal activities like sitting in a chair, on a toilet seat, putting on shoes or getting into a car. Simply climbing stairs may also be more difficult during recovery when following the conventional replacement surgery. These restrictions, simply do not apply after hip replacement using the anterior approach technique.
Following the anterior approach surgical procedure, patients are instructed to use their hip normally without cumbersome restrictions and are sent home from the hospital often in just two days. Patients can immediately bend their hip freely and bear full weight when comfortable, resulting in a rapid return to normal function. Patients and doctors alike are encouraging this method because it reduces pain, blood loss, scarring, muscle trauma and the risk of dislocation.
Advantage Four: More Accurate. The use of a specialized X-ray machine known as a fluoroscope allows the surgeon to see the placement of the component parts of the hip prosthesis in real time and to make adjustments immediately. This is necessary to give the patient the most accurately placed hip prosthesis and to assure equal leg lengths before leaving the operating room. Gait disturbances resulting from a hip replacement made too long or left too short would be very rare with this technique.
Again, the “anterior approach” to hip replacement surgery allows the surgeon to reach the hip joint from the front of the hip in contrast to the lateral (side) or the posterior (back) approach which are by far the most commonly used approaches to the hip currently used in this country. This way, the hip can be replaced without detachment of muscle from the pelvis or femur during surgery as is required in traditional surgery. The surgeon can simply work through the natural interval between the muscles. The most important muscles for hip function, the gluteal muscles and external rotators of the hip that attach from the pelvis to the posterior hip and femur, are left undisturbed and, therefore, do not require a healing process to recover from surgical trauma.
So you may be wondering, if the anterior approach to the hip is so much better, why doesn’t every surgeon use this technique? This, indeed, would be a very fair question. The answer, however, is a bit complex. In fact, the anterior approach to hip surgery has been used in Europe since the late 1940’s, but with the use of conventional operating room tables, it is a technically demanding and often a time consuming activity which did not lend itself well to acceptance by American orthopaedic surgeons. Thus, only a very few hip surgeons are currently offering this approach to their patients. In fact, it has been recently estimated that only ~5% of orthopaedic surgeons nationwide are using the anterior approach to hip surgery due to the steep learning curve of this technique. When given the choice, patients clearly prefer the significant advantages that this innovative surgical approach provides!
Minimally Invasive Total Hip Replacement Operation and Rapid Recovery Made Possible with Latest Instruments
In recent years, however, a breakthrough in design of a specialized operating table developed by a senior orthopaedic surgeon in California and called the “Hana® arthroplasty table” has rekindled the interest of hip surgeons in this most minimally invasive of all surgical hip approaches. The table has unique capabilities to facilitate this smaller and less invasive approach.
A patient is positioned lying flat on their back with both legs stretched out on carbon fiber spars which support the legs and can move appropriately to manipulate the operated leg into various positions required during surgery. This positioning is the key to this anterior approach as it allows the use of live time X-ray guidance during the surgery to assess the position of the artificial hip components and allow for a more accurate measurement of leg lengths at the time of surgery. Additionally, the table has a sterile motorized robotic attachment that reaches inside the wound and lifts the femur to an accessible position which is the most difficult part of the anterior approach without this unique device.
Accordingly, implementation of both this unique surgical table and the “direct anterior approach” technique is Dr. Zehr’s preference for primary total hip replacement. He uses this approach and specialized table for virtually all of his hip replacement surgeries and has done so for the past 7 years in which he has done nearly 1300 hip replacements with this approach. This is truly a revolutionary advance in the field of hip replacement surgery and the results in our patients have been nothing short of amazing.
If this breakthrough approach to hip replacement surgery interests you as it does most patients in need of hip surgery, please click on the following video attachments for more information on this innovative technique or call (239) 596-0100 for an appointment with Dr. Zehr to discuss your situation further.
Animation of Direct Anterior Approach Total Hip Replacement
Mini Posterior Approach
A far more traditional approach to the hip has been through the posterior-lateral approach which is favored by most hip surgeons today. Over the recent years many surgeons have been able to reduce the surgical incision and detachment of surrounding musculature when performing this approach in hip replacement surgery. In the past a typical surgical procedure performed by Dr. Zehr has been through a “mini-posterior approach” with a 3″ skin incision and only a fraction of the muscle detachment usually required by most surgeons to gain access to the hip joint through this approach. When compared to standard surgical incisions with this approach, this minimally invasive technique results in far less post-operative pain, a much quicker rehabilitation and return to full activity.
Although the mini posterior approach for a total hip replacement is a very good and standard approach used by most surgeons, it is still one in which muscle is detached that must then be repaired after the implants are placed. Any muscle splitting or detachment increases the pain felt post-operatively and healing of this repair takes several weeks. In addition, a posterior approach to the hip has some intrinsic and increased risk of dislocation that, although rare, is still a concern. Despite these worries Dr. Zehr’s typical patient for whom a posterior approach was chosen is usually still able to return to normal activities such as golf, biking, swimming, doubles tennis and long distance walking in just 4-6 weeks after surgery.
Below are pre-op and post-op X-rays of an arthritic hip which underwent a total hip replacement using a Ceramic femoral head on an E-Poly bearing surface through a direct anterior approach and is doing very well.
|Ceramic on E-Poly Total Hip|